| Regular Season: Week 1 |
 Cardinals |
at |
 Colts |
Sunday, September 1, 1996 |
3:00PM |
ARI 13, IND 20 |
| Regular Season: Week 2 |
Colts |
at |
 Jets |
Sunday, September 8, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 21, NYJ 7 |
| Regular Season: Week 3 |
Colts |
at |
 Cowboys |
Sunday, September 15, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 25, DAL 24 |
| Regular Season: Week 4 |
 Dolphins |
at |
Colts |
Monday, September 23, 1996 |
3:00PM |
MIA 6, IND 10 |
| Regular Season: Week 6 |
Colts |
at |
 Bills |
Sunday, October 6, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 13, BUF 16 |
| Regular Season: Week 7 |
 Ravens |
at |
Colts |
Sunday, October 13, 1996 |
3:00PM |
BAL 21, IND 26 |
| Regular Season: Week 8 |
 Patriots |
at |
Colts |
Sunday, October 20, 1996 |
3:00PM |
NE 27, IND 9 |
| Regular Season: Week 9 |
Colts |
at |
 Redskins |
Sunday, October 27, 1996 |
2:00PM |
IND 16, WAS 31 |
| Regular Season: Week 10 |
 Chargers |
at |
Colts |
Sunday, November 3, 1996 |
3:00PM |
SD 26, IND 19 |
| Regular Season: Week 11 |
Colts |
at |
Dolphins |
Sunday, November 10, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 13, MIA 37 |
| Regular Season: Week 12 |
Jets |
at |
Colts |
Sunday, November 17, 1996 |
3:00PM |
NYJ 29, IND 34 |
| Regular Season: Week 13 |
Colts |
at |
Patriots |
Sunday, November 24, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 13, NE 27 |
| Regular Season: Week 14 |
Bills |
at |
Colts |
Sunday, December 1, 1996 |
3:00PM |
BUF 10, IND 13 |
| Regular Season: Week 15 |
 Eagles |
at |
Colts |
Thursday, December 5, 1996 |
3:00PM |
PHI 10, IND 37 |
| Regular Season: Week 16 |
Colts |
at |
 Chiefs |
Sunday, December 15, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 24, KC 19 |
| Regular Season: Week 17 |
Colts |
at |
 Bengals |
Sunday, December 22, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 24, CIN 31 |
| Wild Card: Week 18 |
Colts |
at |
 Steelers |
Sunday, December 29, 1996 |
3:00PM |
IND 14, PIT 42 |